# Setting up for success: our transition back to a company
> https://tree-nation.com/projects/inside-tree-nation/article/26033-setting-up-for-success-our-transition-back-to-a-company

- **Author**: Tree-Nation
- **Published**: 2024-06-03T06:56:33.000000Z

Written by Max Renaudin, Tree-Nation Founder and CEOYou may not be familiar with Tree-Nation's humble beginnings. We were established in 2006. Funnily, the whole idea was born on the first of January. Though we started out as a company, in 2019 we transitioned to a non-profit (NGO) structure without much fanfare. Today, we are officially returning to a company structure. Why we started as a company, why the initial change, and why are we going back to our origins? These are the questions I will discuss in this article, hoping to provide insight into our past, but especially, our vision for the future.To save you the long reading, let’s put our conclusion right at the start: a structure is just a shell, a legal framework to operate and serve our mission of planting one trillion trees by 2050. What matters much more, we believe, is the team within it, and the motivations and aspirations that drive this team. Those motivations need to be genuine and support our mission. Behind the paperwork changes and accounting adjustments, our team is the same (just growing), our mission is the same (just bigger), and our dedication remains set in stone.Behind all the swinging, ironically, what motivated the three decisions regarding our structure format, each at a very different time in 2006, 2019 and 2024 is exactly the same: to set ourselves up for success to reach our mission.Beyond this point I must warn you that the article may feel long, but I think you may be interested to understand not just the result, but also the thoughts that led us to these decisions.It feels simpler to describe those three periods (and choices) in chronological order:2006 Let’s transport ourselves to 2006. When I started Tree-Nation my friends thought I went crazy. It made no sense to them why I would try to create a project to plant trees. In a world that still had no idea what a smartphone was, the climate consciousness that we see today did not exist. More importantly for our project, the relationship between trees and CO2, and hence the role that trees could play in climate services was not popular knowledge. Indeed, it is remarkable how commonplace this knowledge has become in today’s world!&nbsp;When it was time to become incorporated, I had a choice between creating Tree-Nation under a company or an NGO structure. The obvious choice was to be an NGO, as our mission was to change the world. Maybe this is why I was tempted by the other option. After all, when you set yourself on an overzealous mission to make a change in the world, you don’t limit your originality to your mission. Your moral compass, your vision, your work ethic, your strategy, everything you do, has to be original and genuine. After all, the whole point was to do things differently from a society set on destroying its own habitat. I knew little about NGOs, international aid, or even forestry back then. So I studied. I deep dived into the wealth of scientific papers that existed on the matter of NGOs and their field results… or lack thereof. Scientific papers felt like a good source because they didn’t try to embellish their results. I read enough reports and books on the topic to come to the personal conclusion that, despite their admirable goals, many NGO projects were not successful. Why was that?&nbsp;What I could observe was that NGOs lacked some business spirit. “Business” is a word that has evolved to hold a negative connotation in our society. We are quick to forget where humanity comes from and what we’ve achieved. Just look at everything that surrounds you, the clothes you wear, the chair you sit on, or the device you use to read these words. Companies have changed the world, in many good ways, with the clear exception of the protection of our environment. Even on social terms, countries with the most successful companies also have the best infrastructures, the freest information, the greatest supply of food and medicine and the wealthiest people. Business is simply an effective vehicle to achieve growth and wealth distribution.Why then, weren’t NGOs adopting a business mindset? The answer, I could guess, was that sometimes the system has a flaw. Businesses need an incentive to operate, and in some situations there was none. There may not be a business incentive to feed people suffering from hunger, or to help war refugees. In truth, while incentives may exist, they may only offer long-term rewards or fail to solve urgent issues. Further, they may not outweigh the risks of operating in difficult conditions. Sometimes no money can be sourced by means of a corporation, so an NGO based on charity and donation is a model that is best suited to raise funds.But the problem is not the ability to raise funds- we could argue that NGOs are superior at this. The problem is how those funds will be used. Let me share a simple but illustrative example: an NGO goes to a small village in Africa that has no access to water. Its villagers, often the kids, are forced to walk many kilometers to access water. Cultivating with irrigation is out of the question. This is quite a familiar story. Enter the NGO, arriving from the dusty road with their shiny white 4x4. After a brief chat with the village council, they agree to install a well. For this they will have to drill 30 meters underground, install a hydraulic pump, and a small solar power system linked to an electric generator. The system is self-sufficient. It is beautiful. It works. Mission accomplished. A commemorative photo is a must, and the NGO is gone. Before leaving they inform that the well is the property of the village, and elect a responsible for its upkeep. However, because an NGO has no business spirit, there is no financial plan created. The well is entirely free. For two years, everything is great. Then the pump fails and it costs 1,000 € to replace. It is not such a big investment when you think about the 20,000 € it had cost to build the well in the first place. However, nobody in the village has the money to cover the repair, and they find themselves without water, again. One year later, all the solar panel’s equipment is gone, sold on the market. I’ve seen this story repeat itself over and over as I traveled through the villages of Niger, Africa. Sometimes these were entirely abandoned, the only remains of the NGO being the weathered billboard and concrete platform that they once erected.What would have happened if the project had been handled by a business? Before leaving, the company would have spent time training the villager responsible for the well, and setting a modest price for its use. The company could have even transferred this commerce to a local entity to keep control of the well. At some point, the pump would fail and still cost 1,000 € to replace, but funds from the operation of the well would have accumulated to permit the expense of fixing it. It doesn’t shock any of our readers in the developed world to pay for their water consumption. We all pay a company dedicated to this purpose. But somehow we entertain the romantic idea that in the developing world, despite their less efficient and more costly infrastructure, water should magically be free.Let’s consider a rebuttal: nothing prevents an NGO from including the concept of financial planning in their aid plans. In fact, many have learned their lessons and dedicate more resources to this matter now than they did in the ‘80s. But building a financially sustainable business is extremely hard. Even for companies, 9 out of 10 fail at this exercise and do not manage to survive. This is not something that can be shunned, faked, nor partially accomplished. Prioritization, strategic planning, and consistent maintenance is required to ensure the success of any endeavor.&nbsp;Armed with this thought process, and for moral reasons, I launched Tree-Nation as a business. From the beginning, I placed a strong focus on planting only species that could bring some level of revenue to local communities, whether by selling their fruits, seeds, oil, or leaves. I believed that this strategy would improve the odds that we would succeed in our mission. I say “moral reasons” because for financial reasons, it would have been much easier to raise funds as an NGO… it almost miraculously opened doors. This is a realization that would soon dawn on me.&nbsp;2019So, what changed in 2019? It actually started with a phone call a bit earlier than that, in 2017. Back then Tree-Nation was still very small. On the financing side, our business model is to collect funds from both individual and corporate sponsors. Because of our modest size, any large corporate sponsors could make an important difference in our achievements on the field. I received a call from a very well known automobile brand who wanted to plant with us- a potentially big step. All was going very well on the call, but after a few minutes they asked “are you a non-profit?” I answered “no” and proceeded to explain why. The call ended that minute… they could only work with an NGO.Through several experiences like the above, I reluctantly came to the conclusion that if we wanted to make a big impact, we needed to change our structure to that of an NGO, because some very large sponsors were simply out of reach without it. Large companies could give you a list of reasons why they preferred to work with an NGO. In my cynical view, there are only two: it gives them a better image for their marketing, and it grants them certain tax deductions. Accepting this reality and changing our structure would be part of our set up for success.&nbsp;I founded Tree-Nation by undertaking two fights at once: fighting climate change and fighting an idea. Ironically, changing people’s minds was proving harder than changing the climate, as no one seemed to question the preconceived notion that non-profits were good and companies were bad. I wanted to contribute in changing this over simplistic view by setting an example of a company that does good. In fact, all companies should do good. And because we live in this dual structure (for-profit companies versus non-profit organizations), our society is discouraged from comparing them. But we should. For example, we should compare entities like Coca-Cola with entities like Greenpeace, holding them to the same standards. We should be able to make statements like these:“X NGO has an admirable mission, but their execution has not been as good as Y Company.”“Y company has been performing well this year, but their positive impact on the environment is not as good as X NGO.”My point is that, by having a type of structure called a non-profit, we allow for-profit entities to be irresponsible about their environmental and social impact, while focusing solely on growth. Why not refer to NGOs and companies alike as 'entities,' and judge every entity by its impact on our society, on the environment, and on successful execution. An administrative title should not be an excuse to pollute, nor one to fail in your goals.Back in 2019, however, faced with the dilemma that I could change a preconceived notion or focus on our mission to reforest the planet, I chose the latter, thereby giving up an ideal that I believed in. That year, we transitioned our activity to a non-profit structure, the premises of which were:Those premises ended up being wrong.The second one, in particular, is an interesting story. Our first quarter operating as an NGO, ill-advised by an accounting firm, we replaced our invoices to companies with donation receipts. It took us three months to realize that this was not ideal. The concept of a donation is that you give without receiving anything in return, it’s unidirectional. However, during our prior 13 years as a company, we had an objective to make our service a win-win. In fact, a win-win-win-win:&nbsp;To accept donations, you can’t have the sponsor win. That’s the difference between a donation and a sponsorship. A non-profit can perform sponsorship activity, but this would require an invoice, not a donation.During this time, I understood another important truth about non-profit structures. Our company had put a lot of effort into creating win-win services to increase our reach: instead of servicing only the most devout environmentally conscious companies, we built services for all, understanding that sustainability is a long journey and that our role is to accompany, not to judge. Reforestation would require a high volume of supporters, so onboarding only 1 or 2% of all companies wouldn’t cut it. Astonished, I realized that non-profits are,&nbsp;by design, not set up to create and perform win-win services. Donations prohibit that.The choice to adjust was made quickly. Invoking our business spirit, we decided that we should aim to have the best services that we could offer. Donations were abandoned in favor of invoices, which were issued as part of sponsorship activities.&nbsp;The other premise, though wrong, held a grain of truth. Indeed some companies were opening their doors to us because we were an NGO. In spite of that, we found that the sponsors with the highest motivation and genuine interest in improving the environment didn’t care about donations. These companies cared much more about embedding our trees into their own services, planting in volume and making significant impact regularly. The “let’s do a donation if we still have taxes to deduct at the end of the year” was neither a sustainable business model nor the kind of dedication we like to see in our sponsors.2024As the title of this article mentions, our main focus is setting up for success. Our mission is set for 2050. This gives us time to aim for what is the right choice. It became increasingly clear for us that the right model is the for-profit one. Among many reasons, here are the four main ones:Projects:&nbsp;Our priority is our planting projects. Operating as a company will allow us to scale our planting efforts worldwide, increasing the speed at which we work towards getting one trillion trees in the ground by 2050.Talent:&nbsp;We are in a growth phase and identify recruitment as an important factor to our success, because our mission can only be accomplished by a top-notch team. As a non-profit, we found it very hard to compete on the job market. In our search for top talent we are not competing against non-profits, but rather against attractive startups that usually offer share packages to their employees. Since we do not offer shares, we hire our team at a premium, which hinders our growth by incurring extra costs.Services: We seek to build the best services for our sponsors and focus on volume. As previously mentioned, donations are not designed to fulfill this goal.Funds:&nbsp;Tree-Nation does not currently deploy venture capital funds… we don’t need to. Still, we want to keep this option in mind as an opportunity to accelerate the speed of our growth. Because speed matters when climate is on the clock.As a final note, let’s think through what the main difference between a not-for-profit and for-profit entity is. Easy answer: “profit”. Here I must say there is often a lot of confusion about what this little word means in this particular context. It means one thing only: a non-profit cannot distribute “profit” in the shape of dividends to their shareholders (the concept of shareholders doesn’t exist in a non-profit). But it can record surplus income that it will have to reinvest in its growth. Exactly like a startup company would do, making the difference moot. To remove any doubt about our dedication to our mission, we pledge to not collect any profit for shareholders before 2050, the date we have set to achieve our mission. Beyond this point, we will have to reinvent ourselves anyway. For our team, future investors and concerned sponsors, our message is clear: there will NOT be any profit distributed before 2050. All extra funds collected will be reinvested into building our services, expanding our team, and purchasing enough stock of trees and CO2 from our network of projects. This pledge may make it harder to attract venture capital if we decide to pursue this road, but it will serve as the perfect filter to find partners that share our dedication.For me, it’s an easy decision to make. As Tree-Nation’s CEO, founder, and majority shareholder, I have the ability to enforce and maintain these decisions long into the future. In other words, I can’t be influenced. During our period of 13 years as a company, between 2006 and 2019, I spent 10 years without a salary. I kept being motivated solely because I believed then and still believe today that a project such as Tree-Nation is needed and should exist. During this period I made sacrifices, worked double to make ends meet for my family while building Tree-Nation (how I did it is a surprising story, but for another time). I think this is the best guarantee for any sponsor: the unstaunched dedication of our team and its leader to our mission. The rest is paperwork.Now, let's get back to working on our mission!Sincerely, MR
